Encyclopedia of Romantic Nationalism in Europe

Start Over

History-writing : Portuguese

  • History-writingPortuguese
  • Cultural Field
    Texts and stories
    Martins, Pedro

    The writing of history in 19th-century Portugal was inherently linked to the notion of Regeneração (“Regeneration”). Historians would later use this word to describe the post-1851 period in Portuguese history, marked by relative political and socioeconomic stability – in comparison with the turbulent first half of the 19th century, punctuated as it had been by the Napoleonic invasions (1807-11), the transfer of the royal court to Brazil (1807), the independence of Brazil (1822), and the successive revolutions and civil wars that accompanied the establishment of a constitutional regime. However, Regeneração was also the word that liberal intellectuals – and among them, historians – used for a desire to “return to origins”. This desire was deeply entrenched in a Romantic mentality, which looked to the past as a basis for restoring or reviving the “declining and feeble” Portuguese nation.

    Among these historians, Alexandre Herculano de Carvalho e Araújo (1810–1877) stands out as one of the harbingers of Romanticism in Portuguese history-writing and fiction. A conservative liberal, Herculano participated in the military revolt of August 1831 against the absolutist restoration, following which he went into exile in England and France. There, he became acquainted with the works of Chateaubriand, Walter Scott and Victor Hugo, and historians such as Wilhelm von Humboldt, Niebuhr, Savigny, Eichhorn, Guizot, Thierry, and Ranke.

    In 1832 Herculano returned to support the liberal cause in the Portuguese civil war. After the victory of the liberals, he was invited in 1837 by the Sociedade Propagadora dos Conhecimentos Úteis (“Society for the propagation of useful knowledge”) to edit the literary journal Panorama. This periodical, with its considerable circulation of 5000 copies, contributed to the spread both of the historical novel and of historical accounts, which represented roughly a quarter of the contents. That was in large part due to the contributions of Herculano himself, but also of other authors such as António Feliciano de Castilho (1800–1875), who in 1839 published there his Quadros Históricos de Portugal. In 1842, another journal, Revista Universal Lisbonense, founded by Castilho in 1841, published in its turn Herculano’s “Cartas sobre a História de Portugal”, inspired by Thierry’s Lettres sur l’histoire de France (1827). In this work, Herculano first advanced his thesis that the Middle Ages had been a glorious period in Portuguese history, in contrast with the subsequent political, moral and socioeconomic decadence of the Early Modern period. Herculano reiterated this view in his “Cogitações Soltas de um Homem Obscuro” (“Wayward thoughts of an obscure man”, likewise published in the Revista Universal Lisbonense, 1846): national decadence is linked to Portugal’s maritime expansion. Although this thesis was not altogether new – it had been anticipated since the 16th century – it gained momentum in the 19th-century Medievalism of Romantic historiographical accounts.

    “Cartas sobre a História de Portugal” formed the basis for Herculano’s História de Portugal, published in four volumes between 1846 and 1853. Planned to encompass most of Portuguese history, this work ended up being much more restricted in its temporal coverage, ending in the late 13th century with Afonso III’s reign. The was largely due to Herculano’s relative disregard for post-medieval history, but also to his other historiographical projects and the controversies raised by his debunking of national myths, notably the so-called “Miracle of Ourique” (where a military victory in 1139 was believed to have been due to heavenly intervention). In addition to its solid documentation and method, the História de Portugal marked the introduction of economic, cultural, and mentality-historical perspectives. On the strength of this achievement, Herculano was made a member (and later vice-president) of the Lisbon Academy of Sciences, charged with the task of supervising the Portugaliae Monumenta Historica. Based on its German prototype, this collection of primary sources on Portuguese medieval history commenced publication in 1856 and went on well after Herculano’s death.

    During his work on the Portugaliae Monumenta Historica, Herculano published História da origem e estabelecimento da Inquisição em Portugal (“History of the origin and establishment of the Inquisition in Portugal”, 1854-59). It painted a dark picture, linking the Portuguese Inquisition to the growing power of the monarchy since the 15th century.

    Herculano’s main successor, Luís Augusto Rebelo da Silva (1822–1871) also combined the writing of history and of historical novels. In 1859 he became one of the first lecturers of the newly created Curso Superior de Letras, the first higher-educational curriculum in Portugal exclusively dedicated to the study of history, philosophy and literature. In works like História de Portugal nos Séculos XVII e XVIII (1860) and Memória sobre a População e a Agricultura de Portugal (1868), Rebelo da Silva drew on Herculano’s theories on the formation of the Portuguese kingdom and the causes of the nation’s decadence, but extended his predecessor’s period span and thematic coverage.

    Although Portuguese Romantic historiography was largely liberal in orientation, certain more traditionalist authors also contributed to the field, e.g. Manuel Francisco de Barros e Sousa de Mesquita de Macedo Leitão e Carvalhosa (1791–1856), better known as the second Viscount of Santarém. Santarém saw his political career thwarted by his involvement in the absolutist governments of King Miguel (r. 1828-34), but left an important mark as a historian of institutions (Memória para a história e teoria das Cortes gerais, 1827-28), maritime expansion (Memória sobre a prioridade dos descobrimentos portugueses na costa de África Ocidental, 1841) and diplomacy (Quadro elementar das relações políticas e diplomáticas de Portugal com as diversas potências do mundo, 1842-76). These works show the influence of Guizot, Ranke, and Thiers, a rigorous application of modern historiographical methods and, similarly to Santarém’s liberal counterparts, a strong belief that history could play a regenerative role in Portuguese society.

    Word Count: 948

    Article version
  • Catroga, Fernando; “Alexandre Herculano e o historicismo romântico”, in Torgal, Luís Reis; Mendes, José Amado; Catroga, Fernando (eds.); História da história em Portugal sécs.XIX-XX (Lisbon: Círculo de Leitores, 1996), 39-85.

    Martins, Pedro; History, nation and politics: The Middle Ages in modern Portugal, 1890-1947 (doctoral thesis; Lisbon: Universidade Nova de Lisboa, 2016).

    Martins, Pedro; “History, nation, and modernity: The idea of «Decadência» in Portuguese medievalist discourses (1842-1940)”, Journal of the History of Ideas, 81 (2020), 451-471.

    Protásio, Daniel Estudante; Pensamento histórico e acção política do 2º Visconde de Santarém (1809-1855) (n.pl.: [the author], 2016).

    Silva, João Lourival da Rocha Oliveira e; O Panorama (1837-1844): Jornalismo e Ilustração em Portugal na Primeira Metade de Oitocentos (Covilhã: Livros LabCom, 2014).

  • Creative Commons License
    All articles in the Encyclopedia of Romantic Nationalism in Europe edited by Joep Leerssen are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at https://www.spinnet.eu.

    © the author and SPIN. Cite as follows (or as adapted to your stylesheet of choice): Martins, Pedro, 2022. "History-writing : Portuguese", Encyclopedia of Romantic Nationalism in Europe, ed. Joep Leerssen (electronic version; Amsterdam: Study Platform on Interlocking Nationalisms, https://ernie.uva.nl/), article version, last changed 23-03-2022, consulted 13-04-2024.